Phil Smith's Sunderland player ratings vs Manchester United as duo impress on tough day

Phil Smith offers his take on the Sunderland squad’s display in the trip to Manchester United at Old Trafford

Sunderland faced another significant test of their Premier League credentials as they went head-to-head with Manchester United at Old Trafford. For Régis Le Bris and his players, the occasion represented not just the challenge of taking on one of English football’s most historic clubs, but also the chance to further underline their encouraging start to life back in the top flight.

The Black Cats went into the fixture with momentum and belief, buoyed by early-season performances that have already shown they can compete at this level. With a passionate away following behind them and a demanding stage in front, the spotlight was on how Le Bris’ youthful squad, mixed with experienced recruits, would handle the occasion.

As always, chief football writer Phil Smith delivers his verdict on the Sunderland squad’s display, analysing every performance from the starting XI to those who came off the bench:

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice