James Copley’s Sunderland notebook: Mystery ‘trialist', funny Florent Ghisolfi moment and why some stories should wait
James Copley reflects on a Sunderland ‘trialist’ mix-up, a revealing Florent Ghisolfi moment and where the line should be drawn
This week’s Sunderland notebook begins with two fairly harmless stories that made me laugh and probably say something about the people involved – although, in the first instance, what it mainly says is that Phil Smith and I can occasionally be a bit dim.
There was a mystery “trialist” in France, a revealing first interaction with Florent Ghisolfi and then, unfortunately, a much more serious subject around the way deeply personal news involving former Sunderland players can spread online.
The mystery Sunderland ‘trialist’ who really wasn’t a trialist
Phil Smith was out in Lens on Saturday while I was providing remote assistance from the considerably less glamorous surroundings of Grangetown, Sunderland.
Phil headed to the first fixture of the day, when a youthful Black Cats side took on a Lens XI before the senior teams met later in the afternoon. As usual with these sorts of games, one of the early jobs was trying to work out exactly who Sunderland had selected. Photos started flying backwards and forwards between us as the players warmed up. Some were obvious, others required a bit more concentration, and then there was one player who completely stumped us.
Who on earth was the tall, left-sided centre-back? Neither of us could place him. We went through the academy players in our heads and nothing fitted. Had Sunderland brought a trialist with them? Was there somebody new training with the group who we had somehow completely missed? It got to the point where messages were sent to contacts and a little bit of digging began. I had half a mind to start preparing the bones of an article and social posts about Sunderland fielding a mystery trialist.
Thankfully, before either of us did anything stupid, the penny finally dropped. It was Aji Alese. Alese had shaved his head and, from the pictures we were working from, somehow managed to look sufficiently different that two journalists who have watched him play countless times could not identify him. There was a fairly long pause in the WhatsApp conversation when the realisation hit, followed by quite a lot of laughter.
It could have been mildly embarrassing had we rushed something out claiming Sunderland had a mysterious new centre-back on trial, only for somebody to immediately point out that it was a player who has been at the club for four years.There is probably a useful lesson in there somewhere.
In the rush to be first, particularly around transfers and pre-season when unfamiliar faces naturally create interest, taking an extra five minutes to make absolutely sure of something is rarely a bad idea. It also proves that even the supposedly knowledgeable pair from The Echo can occasionally be completely useless. Sorry, Aji.
The Florent Ghisolfi moment that broke the ice
The second story takes me back to earlier in the summer when a group of us sat down with Florent Ghisolfi and Tom Burwell to discuss Sunderland’s transfer strategy and commercial plans. It was an enjoyable and fruitful conversation that we have covered extensively across The Echo’s written and video output since, but one tiny interaction before the interview has stuck in my mind.
I arrived at the Stadium of Light’s main entrance at roughly the same time as Scott Wilson from the Northern Echo. His colleague Dom Shaw followed shortly afterwards, as did Phil. We were probably 10 or 15 minutes early. As it happened, so was Ghisolfi. Sunderland’s sporting director walked through the glass doors, immediately came over, shook everyone’s hand and introduced himself. He was incredibly polite and, within about a minute, produced a moment that made all of us smile.
Ghisolfi turned to the member of security on the main entrance and asked whether it was okay that he had parked his car in the spaces directly opposite the doors. The club employee seemed to stop for a second while processing the question before laughing. The basic response was that if anybody other than the owner was entitled to park there, Sunderland’s sporting director was probably going to be all right.
It was only a small interaction, but I found it quite revealing. Here was one of the most powerful people at the football club, somebody responsible for deals worth tens of millions of pounds, still checking with the person on the door that he had not parked somewhere he shouldn’t. Manners cost nothing.
It also immediately broke the ice ahead of what could otherwise have been quite a formal conversation. Ghisolfi has a significant job and will ultimately be judged on the decisions he makes, not whether he asks nicely where he can leave his car. But first impressions matter, and I liked him instantly.
Some news simply should not be a race
Unfortunately, the final part of this notebook is much less light-hearted. I was really sorry to hear that former Sunderland defender Denver Hume had been forced to retire after suffering a life-threatening brain injury in training last year.
What bothered me considerably was that news of Hume’s retirement began circulating before there had been any official announcement from his club or statement from the player himself. There is a distinction that sometimes gets forgotten in the constant chase for information online. A football transfer is fair game. Team news is fair game, albeit something clubs understandably want to protect. Contract discussions, tactical decisions and selection calls are all part of covering professional sport.
Someone’s private medical situation is different. Unless there is a clear public-interest justification, health information deserves particular care. In my view, finding out something deeply personal about a player does not automatically give you the right to publish it simply because you have discovered it first.
The same principle applies to bereavement. We saw something similarly upsetting recently following the death of a major Sunderland legend. Plans had been put in place around how and when the news would be communicated publicly, with the wishes of the family understandably at the heart of that process.
Instead, information from a private social media account was shared publicly by a prominent Sunderland-focused aggregator before the agreed announcement could be made. That forced matters to move more quickly than intended and, most importantly, caused unnecessary distress to people who were already grieving.
That simply is not on. There is enormous competition around Sunderland coverage now, whether between traditional media organisations, independent sites, fan accounts, aggregators or individuals on social media. Some of that competition is healthy. It produces more coverage, more debate and more choice for supporters.
The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.
But being first cannot be the only consideration. Journalism – and really any form of publishing to a large audience – also involves judgement. Sometimes you possess information and the correct decision is still not to publish it. There will always be grey areas and different interpretations of what constitutes the public interest. I certainly do not pretend to get every judgement right.
But news about a serious medical condition or somebody’s death should surely prompt an obvious question before anyone presses send: who benefits from me being first with this? If the answer is essentially your own account, your own engagement or your own reputation, while the person involved or their family potentially suffers, I think the decision should be straightforward. Some stories are worth being beaten on. Those are two very obvious examples.
