Exclusive:James Copley’s Sunderland notebook: Tom Burwell in spotlight, Matty Young’s next step and academy calls

A look at academy futures, Tom Burwell’s early Sunderland fan engagement and Matty Young’s next loan step

This is the third edition of the Sunderland notebook, so hopefully by now you have a rough feel for what we are trying to do with it.

The idea is not to force every bit of information into a standalone story, because not everything works that way. Sometimes there are smaller lines, bits of context, background conversations or little developments that are still worth sharing, even if they sit better together than on their own.

That is what this notebook is for - a slightly more informal look at a few things going on around Sunderland, with a bit of explanation from behind the scenes where it is useful.

That time of year again at the academy

Over the last few days, I have been taking calls, sending messages and touching base with people around the futures of various Sunderland youngsters. You will have seen some of those stories appear on the website already, and a few more bits will probably follow in the days ahead.

From the outside, these stories can look fairly straightforward. A player is out of contract, a club is interested, a loan could happen, someone may move on. That is football. But behind every one of those lines is a young person trying to work out what comes next in their life. For some players, the dream they have worked towards for years will start to fade. That is the brutal reality of football, even at Sunderland, who are one of the nicest clubs around when it comes to looking after young players.

It is one of the harder parts of the job. These are not just names on a list. They are young lads who have grown up chasing something, often with families who have sacrificed so much in the background, and suddenly, they are having to think seriously about the next step. Some will bounce back and make it in senior men’s football, going on to play in the EFL or National League and forging a proper career in the game. Some may move into coaching. Some will head further down the pyramid into semi-professional football or even Sunday league. Some, sadly, will drop out of the game altogether.

I have seen a wide range of different paths over the years. Carl Lawson and Rees Greenwood now run their own coaching business. Jordan Cook, who was in the same academy class as Jordan Henderson, is now a wind turbine technician after hanging up his boots. Others, like Ryan Noble, you just do not really hear anything about anymore. If someone knows him, get in touch, because I would love to have a chat.

I was also touching base with Harry Gardiner’s family over the weekend. He has had a terrible time with injuries since leaving Sunderland and is currently recovering from a broken arm suffered while playing for Dunston, following previous issues and niggles. That is the human side of football, you do not always see after players leave. The story does not just end when someone walks out of the Academy of Light.

Tom Burwell steps into the spotlight

Another person now stepping into a very different kind of spotlight is Tom Burwell. It has been encouraging to see him engaging with supporters after starting his role as interim CEO, because there is a fair bit in his in-tray already.

There have been some well-documented problems with ticketing, and that has understandably led some fans to question the direction of the club off the field. Burwell has essentially replaced David Bruce, who was hugely popular for delivering, in basic language, good things to people.

That might sound a bit simple, but it is probably the best way to put it. Bruce had built strong relationships across the fanbase and had a reputation for getting things done. Supporters felt they could speak to him, and fan groups felt there was a line of communication there. Burwell now has to build that trust in his own way.

From that point of view, there have been some positive early signs. He has already met with RAWA to address concerns, was present at Sunderland’s end-of-season awards, and I have heard he is also due to be present at another fans’ collective meeting. More importantly, he has also been getting directly involved in some of the ticketing issues that have caused supporters real distress in recent weeks.

Nobody expects every problem to be solved overnight, and nobody sensible expects a football club to get every single decision right. But when mistakes are made, supporters want to feel like the club is listening, that somebody senior understands the frustration, and that there is a genuine willingness to fix things.

Burwell getting down into the detail of some of those cases is a good thing, and it deserves to be recognised. It is not glamorous work, it is not the sort of thing that gets shouted about in glossy statements, but it is exactly the kind of labour that can rebuild confidence if supporters feel their concerns are being treated properly.

Massive credit must also go to RAWA and the BLC for the role they have played in helping some of these cases move towards a resolution after they were highlighted publicly by The Echo. That is how this should work. Supporters raise concerns, fan groups push for answers, the media shines a light on the issue, and the club responds.

Nobody wants to write negative stories about Sunderland - least of all me. But sometimes the club has to be held to account. That is not about being difficult for the sake of it, or looking for problems where they do not exist. It is just a vital function of the fanbase. When things go wrong, supporters are often the first to notice, and they are usually the ones best placed to remind the club of what it is supposed to stand for.

Matty Young’s next step

One Sunderland youngster whose next move will be watched with real interest is Matty Young, who is on the verge of signing a new deal at the Academy of Light. Ryan Giggs, Gary Neville and Paul Scholes rolled out the red carpet to sign him at Salford City again last summer, and it is fair to say Salford’s high-profile ex-Manchester United figures have been seriously impressed.

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

Young is seen by both Sunderland and Salford as someone who could potentially play for England one day, which is obviously no small thing to say about any young goalkeeper. Giggs, Neville and Scholes know a bit about top-level talent, too, so their judgement carries some weight. But what has stood out at Salford is not just Young’s ability - it is his mentality.

Being a number one in the EFL at such a young age brings pressure, scrutiny and responsibility, and by all accounts, he has handled it impressively. Sunderland have always hoped Young could follow a Jordan Pickford-type route. Go out, play senior football, deal with proper pressure and come back better for it. Salford has served a purpose, and a very useful one at that, but I have been told he will not return there for a third season.

The feeling is that a new environment is now needed. A bigger club, bigger fanbase, bigger stadium and a different kind of challenge. That takes nothing away from Salford or the role they have played in his development, and you can never say never in football. It just feels like the natural next step has to stretch him again.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice