James Copley: Sunderland already have a transfer solution – but will Kristjaan Speakman pull the trigger?

Why Sunderland may not need the market to solve one key transfer decision during the winter window

Transfer windows have a habit of drawing the eye outward. New names, new leagues, new possibilities. On social media, it can all become a bit Football Manager or FIFA-like – shortlists, wish lists, screenshots and dream signings. And rightly so. These moves are exciting. They always have been.

But sometimes the smartest solution is not found in a scouting report or an overseas short-list, but much closer to home. Sunderland are once again being linked with external options in key areas, yet there is a growing case that one of their most important decisions this window and beyond does not involve a signing at all, but a contract.

Dennis Cirkin is exactly the type of player I would be looking to tie down. He is young, still only 23, and – having interviewed him several times over the years, most recently after his first Premier League start against Leeds – I get the clear impression that he genuinely loves Sunderland. That matters. It always has.

Cirkin is now into the final six months of his contract, which inevitably sharpens the focus. The obvious question is whether he would be content playing second fiddle to the outstanding Reinildo Mandava for the next couple of seasons. That is not a small consideration. But football rarely stays static. Injuries, form and tactical shifts can alter the landscape far quicker than anyone anticipates – and Cirkin’s own injury record is perhaps the biggest question mark of all.

Even so, it would feel strange if Sunderland were to walk away now. The club took a calculated risk on him as a teenager, gave him a platform from League One to the Premier League, and watched him play a key role in two promotions. To let him leave just as he begins to realise his value feels counterintuitive – though I said the same about Dan Neil, and we all know how that ended. Kristjaan Speakman and Florent Ghisolfi will, of course, make their own calls, and it would be hard to argue with them given Sunderland’s recent success.

Sunderland have already been linked with several left-backs this summer, but there is a strong argument that a solution already exists within the squad. To replace Cirkin with a player of similar profile – age, ability, Premier League experience and upside – would cost money. Even a relatively modest fee, amortised over a long contract, would still eat into PSR and SCR headroom down the line. When you already have that asset in-house, letting him go and then spending again feels inefficient.

The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.

That is not to say this is straightforward. We do not know what Cirkin wants. He may crave guaranteed starts. He may feel the time is right for a new challenge. Contract negotiations are usually driven by three things: money, status and opportunity – and Cirkin will naturally assess all three. From Sunderland’s perspective, there will be similar questions. Do they believe greater value can be found in the market? Do they feel they can upgrade the position and push the squad forward again next season? We have already seen the club’s hierarchy significantly raise the level of recruitment, and perhaps there are more Granit Xhaka or Nordi Mukiele-type signings in the pipeline.

But squad building is not only about constant replacement. It is also about retention, continuity and protecting value. Cirkin is still developing, still learning, and still at an age where his best football could lie ahead of him. Letting him drift towards the exit now, without at least making a serious attempt to extend his deal, would feel like a missed opportunity. For me, the case is simple. Offer him a new contract. See where the conversation leads. If it does not align, so be it. But Sunderland should not allow a player they invested in so heavily – financially and developmentally – to walk away without first testing whether the future could still be shared.

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice