Granit Xhaka's fury and funny Jordan Pickford moment after England man joins Sunderland chant – moments missed
The moments you may have missed before, during and after Sunderland’s trip to Everton in the FA Cup...
Sunderland’s FA Cup meeting with Everton came with a clear sense of historical context, shaped by a head-to-head record that has long favoured the Merseyside club.
Heading into the tie, the Black Cats had faced Everton on 185 occasions in all competitions, winning 71, drawing 31 and losing 83. It was a record that underlined the scale of the task, with victories often hard-earned and long spells edged by the Toffees.
The FA Cup added another layer of intrigue. The sides’ most recent meetings in the competition date back to 2012, when Sunderland were held to a draw in the quarter-final at Goodison Park before falling to defeat in a replay just days later at the Stadium of Light.
Here, we take a closer look at the moments you may have missed before, during and after the game, from the key talking points around kick-off to the details that shaped the evening once the dust had settled:
First trip to Everton’s new stadium
Sunderland’s FA Cup trip to Everton marked another small but significant milestone in what had already become a season of firsts on the road. The tie represented the Black Cats’ first-ever visit to Hill Dickinson Stadium since the ground opened for the current campaign, adding fresh surroundings and unfamiliar routines to an already demanding knockout test.
The Echo has launched a new WhatsApp SAFC Channel to bring the latest news, analysis and team & injury updates direct to your phone. Simply click this link to join our SAFC WhatsApp channel.
It also completed a remarkable run of new territory. In the space of just seven days, Sunderland had played senior fixtures at three stadiums they had never previously visited. Last Sunday brought a first competitive outing at Tottenham Hotspur Stadium, before attention quickly shifted to midweek and a maiden trip to Brentford’s Gtech Community Stadium. The journey to Merseyside ensured that sequence continued, underlining how quickly the fixture list had carried Régis Le Bris’ side into uncharted ground.
Régis Le Bris names strong team to face Everton in FA Cup
Régis Le Bris delivered on his pledge to name a strong Sunderland side for the FA Cup third-round trip to Everton, resisting the temptation to rotate heavily despite a demanding run of fixtures. Granit Xhaka retained his place in the starting XI, while Robin Roefs continued in goal, underlining the importance placed on the competition.
Changes to the side that had navigated the AFCON period were kept to a minimum, with Omar Alderete, Dan Ballard and Brian Brobbey the only regular starters to be rested. As a result, Luke O’Nien made his first competitive start of the season, Eliezer Mayenda was handed the responsibility of leading the line, and Romaine Mundle also came in for his first start of the campaign, lining up out wide alongside Simon Adingra.
There was also an immediate boost from AFCON, with Noah Sadiki returning straight into the starting XI, while Wilson Isidor provided further encouragement by taking a place on the bench after missing the previous two games with a minor injury.
Jordan Pickford starts for Everton against Sunderland
David Moyes handed a start to Jordan Pickford against his former club, with the England international facing Sunderland for the second time since his departure in a competitive fixture. It followed his earlier reunion with the Black Cats this season at the Stadium of Light in the Premier League.
Pickford’s connection to Sunderland runs deep. He joined the club’s academy at the age of eight, rising through the age groups before signing scholarship terms in 2010 and earning a professional contract a year later. After several loan spells, he was recalled midway through the 2015-16 campaign with Sunderland battling at the foot of the Premier League, making his senior debut in an FA Cup defeat to Arsenal before stepping into the league side days later.
The 2016-17 season proved decisive. Pickford established himself as first choice, earned widespread praise for a series of standout performances and was shortlisted for the PFA Young Player of the Year award. That form ultimately earned him a move to Everton in the summer of 2017, when he became the most expensive British goalkeeper of all time, a journey that made this latest meeting another notable chapter in his Sunderland story.
Pickford was warmly applauded by both Sunderland and Everton supporters just before kick-off, as the starting XIs for both sides were read out by the stadium announcer, a moment that underlined the respect he continues to command on both sides of his former divide. Reports from social media after the game also claimed that Pickford was spotted joining in with a chant about Lee Howey’s brother.
Enzo Le Fee answers critics as second-half melee erupts
The 8,000-strong Sunderland away end produced a stirring rendition of the Enzo Le Fée chant at Goodison Park, a show of backing that followed this week’s penalty miss against Brentford. The midfielder responded in the perfect way, opening the scoring with a calm, assured finish. Another standout moment of the first half arrived at the other end, when Jordan Pickford produced a superb save to deny an acrobatic overhead-kick attempt from Sunderland centre-back Nordi Mukiele.
Tensions briefly flared in the second half when Romaine Mundle and James Garner came together following a clash that saw the Sunderland winger catch his opponent with a trailing arm. Garner reacted with a firm challenge moments later, but despite a short-lived melee, neither player was shown a booking. Granit Xhaka quickly stepped in to calm proceedings and restore order.
Peter Reid spotted watching Everton vs Sunderland
Everton and Sunderland hero Peter Reid was among those in attendance, taking in a meeting between two clubs that defined large chapters of his career. Reid made his name as a combative, influential midfielder during a seven-year spell at Everton in the 1980s, winning the First Division title, FA Cup and European Cup Winners’ Cup, while also earning England caps during that period.
His connection to Sunderland came later, when he was appointed manager in 1995 and went on to oversee one of the club’s most successful modern eras. Reid guided the Black Cats to promotion from the First Division and later consolidated their Premier League status, becoming a hugely popular figure on Wearside. His appearance in the stands added another layer of nostalgia to an afternoon shaped by shared history and familiar storylines.
Granit Xhaka fumes as Brian Brobbey comes off injured
Everton were awarded a controversial penalty after Adam Aznou went to ground following a shoulder-to-shoulder challenge with Trai Hume. Referee John Brooks pointed to the spot, a decision that appeared soft on replays and one that would likely have been overturned had VAR been in operation. The call proved a major talking point, with Sunderland captain Granit Xhaka visibly furious at full-time as both sides regrouped ahead of an additional 30 minutes of extra time. Xhaka was spotted smashing his water bottle off the floor before extra-time began.
The first half of extra time passed without a goal, but Sunderland were forced into a change when Wilson Isidor was introduced in place of Brian Brobbey. The striker appeared to have picked up a knock after being brought on earlier in the second half to replace Eliezer Mayenda, adding to Sunderland’s concerns as the tie edged deeper into extra time.
Robin Roefs becomes Sunderland’s penalty hero
The tie was ultimately decided by penalties, with Robin Roefs emerging as the hero by saving three of Everton’s spot-kicks. Sunderland kept their nerve from 12 yards, converting through Enzo Le Fée, Granit Xhaka and Luke O’Nien to seal progression. The shootout victory ensured Sunderland reached the fourth round of the FA Cup for only the second time in the last 10 seasons, capping a dramatic night on Merseyside.
After converting his penalty, Granit Xhaka shared a light-hearted exchange with former Sunderland goalkeeper Jordan Pickford, with the pair briefly pointing at each other in an amusing moment following the spot-kick. Xhaka was all smiles after confidently dispatching his effort, while Pickford could only respond with a bemused expression. Luke O’Nien’s winning penalty then triggered wild celebrations, with Xhaka and his Sunderland team-mates racing towards the away end to celebrate in front of the travelling support.
Your next Sunderland read: Sunderland defender makes dressing room pledge after Brentford disappointment
