The Millers netted from a corner in the first half and controlled much of the fixture before Sunderland managed to force an own goal late in the second stanza.
Here, though, we take a look at the latest news doing the rounds:
South Shields suffer penalty heartbreak
Most Popular
-
1
Championship news: Ex-£8m Sunderland midfielder favourite for Birmingham City job despite little experience
-
2
Sunderland AFC news: Ex-Black Cats, Middlesbrough, Huddersfield Town and Stoke City man makes Turkey switch
-
3
Nine strikers Sunderland could try to sign this summer - including Leeds United, Aston Villa and Tottenham youngsters
-
4
Sunderland AFC transfer news: Black Cats have no interest in ex-AC Milan and Chelsea man as 2,300 fans vote on transfer
-
5
Former Sunderland and Crystal Palace striker spotted in-action for Championship side Reading
Former Sunderland man Jordan Hunter was the unfortunate man who saw his penalty saved by Daniel Atherton as South Shields’ season ended with playoff heartbreak against Warrington
Both sides scored four successful penalties and had one saved before Hunter missed the crucial 12th penalty as Warrington went home victorious.
South Shields are managed by ex-Black Cats striker Kevin Phillips but will remain in the Northern Premier League for another season.
Another former Sunderland man, Blair Adams, also plays for the club.
Luke O’Nien delivers Rotherham verdict
Luke O’Nien has delivered his verdict on Rotherham United.
The battling midfielder started the game in the middle for Alex Neil alongside Corry Evans and January signing Jay Matete and was named as Sunderland’s Man of the Match
"Tactically they're a bit difficult to play against, they don't play much on the floor, but we gave ourselves a platform.
"It was my fault for the goal, but we hung on to the end.
"I've found the last three matches really exciting and the momentum we've built up.
"We're stringing it together at the right time of the season.
"We go into every game to win and this time there's just more in it."