YMCA bedsit refused planning permission over antisocial behaviour fears - charity warns of impact on vulnerable people

Earlier this year, the charity lodged a retrospective planning application for a property in Evelyn Street, in the Millfield ward.

This included a four-bedroom house in multiple occupation (HMO) in one of seven houses on the street.

During consultation, the proposals sparked opposition from local councillors, neighbours, local governors for Thornhill Academy and even Northumbria Police.

After being called in for decision by Millfield councillor Niall Hodson over the “level of public interest”, the plans were discussed by Sunderland City Council earlier this week.

At a meeting of the area development control sub-committee on December 16, councillors heard there was a history of recorded crimes and incident reports linked to the property.

Northumbria Police said the premises had been raised at many community meetings with “regular police attendance” in response to reported antisocial behaviour in the past.

Police bosses added that, “as a result of previous experience”, they would be opposed to the planning application if residents were to be “primarily young persons.”

The Thornholme Residents Association, in a representation to the council, said it would be a “significant error to grant this application and further disrupt the lives of the remaining residents.”

Meanwhile, local objectors also noted the “tragic death” of a tenant at the property last year.

Council planners, recommending the plan for refusal, said retaining the HMO would be “contrary to the residential character of Evelyn Street.”

Following discussion, councillors agreed to reject the plans.

In response to a question about the future of the building, planning officers confirmed they may consider a form of enforcement notice to “remedy the situation”.

YMCA Wearside described the decision as “exceptionally disappointing” and have hit back at the council, disputing several claims from objectors.

A spokesperson, speaking after the meeting, added: “Due to a lack of notice given to YMCA, we were unable to provide a response which would have reflected the reality of the situation to local councillors.

“While YMCA are disappointed in the outcome, the real devastation will be to the lives of the young people who have found refuge and safety in this accommodation but who now face uncertainty and worry.”