Phil Smith's Sunderland player ratings: Who shone and who struggled in Stoke City clash?

Sunderland last night beat Stoke City Under-21s on penalties in the Checkatrade Trophy group stage clash after a goalless draw at the Stadium of Light.

By The Newsroom

Published 5th Sep 2018, 09:12 BST

Updated 5th Sep 2018, 09:16 BST

Chris Maguire in action against Stoke City U21s last night.

But who shone and who struggled to make an impression? Click through our gallery of player ratings from Sunderland AFC writer Phil Smith.