Legal Eagle: Local hospital trust admits 20 unnecessary mastectomies
County Durham and Darlington NHS Foundation Trust (CDDFT) has admitted that 20 women underwent mastectomies that, following a review of their care, may not have been necessary.
The admission is part of a wider investigation into the trust's breast care service. Of 514 cases reviewed so far, the trust found that 315 patients suffered some degree of harm, including 77 who experienced significant harm. The review has also identified delayed and missed cancer diagnoses, with some patients seeing their condition worsen as a result. One patient is known to have died.


The review follows concerns about aspects of the breast unit's practices, including higher-than-average mastectomy rates, the timing of some procedures and arrangements under which certain breast cancer services were delivered through private providers linked to the trust's former clinical lead for breast services, Mr Amir Bhatti.
Independent reviews have raised concerns about governance, clinical oversight and adherence to established treatment processes. One governance review also highlighted concerns that outsourcing arrangements may have created financial incentives capable of influencing clinical decision-making, as NHS patients were referred to private clinics and surgical services linked to the consultant overseeing their care. The trust has acknowledged that a conflict of interest existed and was not managed appropriately, although there has been no finding that treatment decisions were made for financial gain.
Review findings also identified concerns that some breast cancer cases may not have been considered through multidisciplinary team meetings in line with expected practice. Such meetings are intended to ensure treatment options are reviewed and challenged by a range of specialists before significant decisions are taken.
Several former patients have since been informed that breast-conserving surgery may have been a viable option in their cases, but that this was not discussed with them at the time. Many have spoken publicly about the lasting physical and psychological impact of their treatment.
Trust chief executive Steve Russell has issued an unreserved apology and described the failings identified by the review as unacceptable. The trust is now considering whether to expand the investigation to include up to 10,000 breast cancer cases dating back to 2015.
Separately, Durham Police and the National Crime Agency are examining allegations arising from the matter to assess whether any criminal offences may have been committed.
The findings raise legitimate questions about oversight, governance and whether warning signs were identified and acted upon quickly enough. If you or anyone you know may be affected by this report we have a team of Clinical negligence specialists available to speak at [email protected].