Man fined but keeps driving licence after refusing breath test in Sunderland city centre
A shopfitter who refused to be breath tested because he claimed he had no intention of driving when quizzed by police in Sunderland has been spared a roads’ ban.
Jamie Edgar, 50, told officers after his arrest he would not risk his job by getting behind the wheel while drunk – and repeatedly rejected their legal request.


Edgar was suspected of being drunk when found in a car in city centre Green Terrace in the early hours of Sunday, November 30.
Officers noted he had glazed eyes and smelled of booze – and they spotted several cans of beer inside his motor, South Tyneside Magistrates’ Court heard.
His solicitor admitted Edgar had misunderstood the law and police could request a breath test if they suspected he may drive, even if not caught in the act.
Edgar, of Wimblebury Road Heath, Cannock, Staffordshire, entered a guilty plea to a charge of failing to provide a specimen - person in charge of a vehicle, but hesitated in doing so.
Sophie Allinson-Howells, defending, said this was because he still struggled to accept he could be charged even though he had not planned to drive.
Magistrates had the power to disqualify him for up to six months but instead imposed 10 penalty points, meaning Edgar can keep motoring.
Prosecutor Rehana Haque said: “A police officer located the defendant in a blue Ford. She had cause to arrest him for being unfit through alcohol.
“He had glazed eyes, and he smelled of intoxicating liquor. She says that he was drunk.
“A CAMIC breath test procedure was requested, and he was asked to provide two samples of breath. He refused.
“In interview, he said, ‘I had no intention of driving the car’. That’s why he refused to provide.”
Mrs Allinson-Howells, who urged magistrates not to ban Edgar, said: “He made it clear to the police that he wasn’t going to drive.
“He’s in full-time work, and uses his car every day. His words to me are, ‘I would not risk my licence on something like this’.
“He didn’t understand but frankly the police don’t care as long as they have followed procedures.”
Magistrates also fined Edgar £576, with a £230 victim surcharge and £85 court costs.