Houghton man showed a blasé attitude to breath tests
A Houghton-le-Spring man with a blasé attitude to breath tests has been spared a roads’ ban after prosecutors admitted there was no evidence he had driven.
Police arrived at Keith Stubbs’ door in Harwood Drive after a report a vehicle parked outside had been involved in a crash on Thursday, October 16.


They found Stubbs apparently drunk, and he was arrested and taken to a police station to be breath tested, South Tyneside Magistrates’ Court heard.
Despite being told failing to do so would see him prosecuted, he refused to blow, informing officers, “I don’t care”.
Stubbs pleaded guilty to a charge of failing to provide a specimen for analysis, an offence which carries a minimum one-year driving ban.
However, District Judge Zoe Passfield instead imposed 10 penalty points after hearing there was no evidence he had driven.
But she warned driving offences carry a minimum three penalty points, with a tally of 12 usually leading to a ban.
The judge told him: “You’re going to have to drive extremely carefully.
“If we see you back in court for any driving offence, you’re looking at disqualification.”
Prosecutor Jade Houston told the hearing: “Officers attended Harwood Drive following a report of a possible drink driver.
“The driver had been witnessed driving a Fiesta into a parked car and being unable to drive away.
“Police attended his flat and they could smell alcohol on him. He was also in possession of the keys of the Ford Fiesta parked outside.
“He was taken to a police station and required to give a breath sample.
“There is no evidence of a high level of impairment. The officers describe him as being drunk.”
David Forrester, defending, said: “It comes under the guideline of a deliberate refusal.
“When told he would be prosecuted if he didn’t provide, he said, ‘I don’t care’.
“He appears to be going through a difficult time. He’s currently off work with depression.
“He tells me it’s not a long-term issue, he’s only been off work for a month. His relationship has broken up.”
Stubbs was also fined £120 and must pay £85 court costs and a £48 victim surcharge.