It feels like a punishment - huge row erupts between pupils, parents and school over leavers hoodies decision

“All the previous Year 11 cohorts have been able to wear their leavers hoodies in their last term and for me it just feels like the kids are being punished and losing part of their right of passage”

The words of parent Andrew Murley who contacted the Echo after receiving a letter from Venerable Bede Church of England Academy outlining the school’s stance that, unlike previous years, leavers hoodies are “not permitted in lessons, corridors, or communal areas during the school day”.

(Inset) parent Andrew Murley feels that pupils are "being punished" after decision not to allow Year 11 pupils to wear their leavers hoodies throughout the school day.placeholder image
(Inset) parent Andrew Murley feels that pupils are "being punished" after decision not to allow Year 11 pupils to wear their leavers hoodies throughout the school day. | Iconic/Andrew Murley

The decision has provoked a massive response from pupils with the whole year group signing a petition for students to be able to wear the hoodies during the school day.

One of those behind the petition is Andrew’s daughter, Emily Murley, 16, who also said the year group had been supported by some members of staff in organising the petition.

Emily said: “One person in our group came up with the idea of a petition and it was signed by the whole year group which is well over 100 students. After consulting one of our our teachers they printed off 15 petition forms and handed them out to some students who then took them to get signed by pupils in our year group.

“We then handed it into the senior leadership team. In the time I’ve been at the school Year 11 pupils were always allowed to wear their leavers hoodies and this just feels unfair and we wanted to do something about it.

“Since the new leadership team came into the school it feels like all of the other year groups have got something out of it with rewards and trips, and being able to wear these hoodies is something we could have had.

“Hopefully the leadership team will take our views into consideration, listen to pupils, and rethink their decision.”

Venerable Bede Academy is part of the Northern Lights Learning Trust.

In her letter to parents, the Trust’s director of secondary education, Nikki Gibb, acknowledged the mature way in which pupils have gone about venting their feelings on the decision.

She said: “Firstly, our student body have been very mature and have let me know, both written and verbally, about their wish to wear their hoodies in the school building during normal school hours. I have read and listened to their responses and I have also been informed of parents’ views on this issue.”

Explaining the thought process behind her decision, Ms Gibb added: “There are several reasons for this decision, but none more so than the focus needing to be on learning and preparation for exams. If hoodies are worn in school, conversations between staff and students become focused on compliance with the rest of the uniform requirements rather than engagement with their studies.

“Ultimately, it is very important that the high standards and expectations of our uniform policy are upheld by all students at all times at Venerable Bede as adopted by the school and Local Governing Body.”

However, Mr Murley said he and other parents he has spoken with don’t agree with the decision.

He said: “I think the idea that wearing their leavers hoodies will distract pupils from their learning just seems like an excuse. Since Emily has been there, the Year 11s have always been allowed to wear their hoodies during the school day and I know from other parents this was the case before she even started at Venerable Bede.

“Since the new leadership team came into the school they have made a lot of changes which have pushed the grades up. Lots of year groups have been given various rewards, but the Year 11s seem to have been left out.

“This just feels like the kids are being punished and losing part of their right of passage. We have ordered Emily’s hoodie as it’s a memento for her to keep about her time at the school, but I know a lot of parents who are not happy about the decision and aren’t now going to be ordering a leavers hoodie for their child.”

In her letter to parents Ms Gibb said: “If parents or carers have already purchased a leavers hoodie and wish to request a reimbursement because the garment cannot be worn (throughout the school day), the school will reimburse this.”

The school has faced a difficult few years and in January (2025) Ofsted inspectors visited the school and deemed the quality of education to be inadequate.

Inspectors returned in September (2025) and identified that significant improvements had been made following the appointment of two deputy headteachers, school improvement leaders, and the Trust appointing an executive director of secondary education.

After being contacted by the Sunderland Echo about the student petition and dispute over the hoodies decision, the trust’s executive director of secondary education, Nikki Gibb said: “All our actions and all decisions made are for the benefit of our students.

“As Venerable Bede continues on its journey of significant school improvement, leaders continue to instil the highest expectations of all the students. This includes displaying strong learning behaviours, attending school regularly and wearing the school uniform with pride in all year groups.

"Students are permitted to wear their leavers' hoodies when travelling to and from school, in PE lessons, at off‑site leavers’ events, or during designated non‑uniform activities approved by the school.

“When in school, students should wear their uniform in line with the policy.

"The school is immensely proud of the Year 11 students and will continue to support them with their studies as well as celebrate their successes."

News you can trust since 1873
Follow us
© 2026 Iconic Media Group Ltd. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice