Player ratings - Aston Villa 2 Sunderland 2

Yann M'Vila in action for Sunderland against Aston Villa. Picture by FRANK REID
Yann M'Vila in action for Sunderland against Aston Villa. Picture by FRANK REID
Have your say

Sunderland reporter Chris Young assesses how the Black Cats players performed in the 2-2 draw at Aston Villa.

Costel Pantilimon: Smart late save kept out Westwood’s shot. But showed some hesitancy in coming for crosses during the first half. 6

Billy Jones: Gave Amavi far too much room to cross for Villa’s second and never looked comfortable when the hosts were going forwards. 5

Younes Kaboul: Much more like the player Sunderland thought they’d signed. Held the defence together and made several crucial interceptions. 8

John O’Shea: Looks happier alongside Kaboul, but still had some dicey moments and perhaps could have done better with the second. 6

Patrick van Aanholt: Offered no protection by Defoe as Hutton kept bombing forwards. Stuck to his task though. 6

Lee Cattermole: No need whatsoever to concede such a cheap penalty, while he was turned too easily by Gana for the second. Needed to be hooked at half-time. 4

Jack Rodwell: Better in the second half, but again seemed to go into that shell of being a passenger. 6

YANN M’VILA: Pinpoint free-kick opened his Sunderland account and he is increasingly becoming the player that dictates proceedings. 8

Jeremain Lens: Grabbed his first Sunderland goal with a crucial equaliser, yet wasn’t as threatening as he had been against Swansea. 7

Jermain Defoe: Was lazy tracking back and miscontrolled a wonderful through-ball from M’Vila, which was his one real chance. 6

Danny Graham: Gave Sunderland no attacking platform whatsoever and rightfully taken off at the interval. 5


Steven Fletcher (for Graham 46): Made more of an impact than Graham and went close with an excellent header. 6

Ola Toivonen (for Cattermole 46): Faded as the half wore on, but started it with a bang and made the equaliser. 7

Seb Larsson (for Defoe 77): Brought on to shore things up. 6

Subs not used: Mannone, Coates, Watmore, Gooch.