Phil Smith's verdict: Long-term failings being laid bare again as Sunderland and Lee Johnson face play-off battle

19 games in, the numbers leave us facing some familiar conclusions.
Watch more of our videos on Shots! 
and live on Freeview channel 276
Visit Shots! now

Sunderland are tracking at 1.57 points-per-game, a rate that if continued over the course of the season, would leave them exactly where they finished last year.

A points total not good enough for the play-offs last year, nor the season before it.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Under Madrox Sunderland have not kicked on since that narrow and bitterly frustrating miss in the 2018/19 season. In fact, they have regressed and considerably so.

Hull City take the lead at the Stadium of LightHull City take the lead at the Stadium of Light
Hull City take the lead at the Stadium of Light

The habit of drawing too many games (39 since dropping into the third tier) is actually accelerating in the current campaign.

The recent run of form leaves us in no doubt that the summer window was another in which the Black Cats failed to make the necessary level of improvement to their squad.

The salary cap made that window a challenge, as did the continuing need to adjust to the significantly reduced revenues Sunderland are now bringing in (a process made even more acute by the ongoing impact of COVID-19.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Yet the chronic underfunding and lack of care paid towards the recruitment department in the last two-and-a-half years meant that the club yet again was unable to get what it needed out of the market.

A lack of pace and a lack of craft has left the Black Cats again trailing the promotion pace.

That would be a worry in any season, but even more pressing given the current climate and how the previous campaign ended.

The recent changes at the club have of course represented an attempt to correct those shortcomings off the pitch, with Kristjaan Speakman and Lee Johnson tasked with building a more dynamic team and a more modern footballing department.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The hope is that the swift ratification of Kyril Louis-Dreyfus' takeover will provide the clear impetus and investment that project requires to stand any chance of being successful.

The change in thinking is welcome; that the best way to secure promotion is to break the short-termist cycle that has left Sunderland where they are now.

To stop thinking of promotion as the be-all and end-all actually might help the Black Cats make the kind of decisions that improve the club's chances of finally getting the better of this division.

In the interim, there can be no doubt now that Johnson is facing an uphill task to deliver that promotion this season.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Right now, Sunderland's form suggests they are in a battle to land a play-off position, never mind automatic promotion.

The congested table of course provides some hope, and there are some important caveats to assess when reflecting on this latest 1-1 draw.

The Black Cats are still searching for momentum after the frustratingly stop-start nature of Johnson's tenure so far, and some key personnel are clearly missing as the head coach searches for a more progressive look to his starting XI.

Luke O'Nien and Denver Hume are particularly big misses, normally bringing an energy and dynamism to the team that is crucial to their attacking threat.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Conor McLaughlin has been solid this season but is currently managing the ongoing effects of a hernia problem and it was notable that Sunderland looked a more balanced and threatening side when Max Power shifted to right-back in the second half.

Power's willingness to overlap opened up options for the Black Cats, and for the most part improved the quality of cross coming towards the Hull defence.

The second half performance was strong, if lacking in a little inspiration.

Sunderland played most of the game in Hull's half and against a side second in the table, that was another point worth dwelling on briefly.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Frustrating as the end result was, it is not this kind of draw that truly threatens Sunderland's promotion ambitions.

Their record against sides around the top six has always been respectable; it is in putting away the sides near the bottom efficiently and consistently that Sunderland's biggest problems lie.

It explains why Johnson is continiung to search for another spark in the final third, his post-match comments strongly suggesting that it is to this department his transfer search will now head following the arrival of Carl Winchester.

In the first half Charlie Wyke was isolated and had little influence on the contest, the Black Cats struggling for creativity in midfield.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Johnson's half-time changes did improve the picture slightly, with Lynden Gooch bringing a welcome added presence high up the pitch.

Gooch is still searching for sharpness after a recent injury but the balance of the side looked far better with him in it, and it was easy to see why Johnson is considering sticking with this experiment if the salary cap obstacles prevent him from making major additions.

It is clear that Johnson will need time to make a significant impact and in the rise of Jack Diamond, there is hope that his talk of building a more dynamic side will come to fruition.

Rough edges remain in Diamond's game but the trust and licence he has been given by Johnson has undoubtedly improved the side.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

The majority of Sunderland's bright moments came down his flank and the way he troubled the Hull defence should give him even more confidence moving forwards.

Johnson has kept his composure through a challenging start to life on Wearside, and his message for the short-term prospects of his side remains one of optimism.

He is pleased they looked solid defensively, is satisfied with the work rate and still believes they can go on the kind of attacking run they now badly need.

He expects the rest of the season to be injury-hit as the hectic schedule bites and like his predecessor, believes his side will cope with that better than most.

Hide Ad
Hide Ad

Make no mistake, though, he is facing a significant challenge.

He has said it is time now to show his teeth and demand more. Sunderland need it. Their shortcomings right now are all too familiar.

A message from the Football Clubs Editor

Our aim is to provide you with the best, most up-to-date and most informative Sunderland AFC coverage 365 days a year.

This depth of SAFC coverage costs, so to help us maintain the high-quality reporting that you are used to, please consider taking out a subscription to our new sports-only package here.

Your support is much appreciated. Richard Mennear, Football Clubs Editor