Phil Smith's Sunderland AFC player ratings: Cats struggle in Charlton play-off defeat with SEVEN players earning 5s
Sunderland lost out to Charlton Athletic in the League One play-off final - but how did their players perform?
Our Sunderland AFC writer Phil Smith has dished out his player ratings, with some low marks following a disappointing afternoon. Scroll down and click through the pages to see how he viewed Sunderland's individual performances: