Aiden McGeady’s first-half strike was cancelled out by Oliver Lee after the interval, with Phil Parkinson’s side now facing the prospect of a replay against the Gills in the coming weeks.
But who shone and who struggled for the Black Cats against their League One rivals? Phil Smith has dished out his player ratings, with some mixed marks. Scroll down and click through the pages to see how he rated the players:
1. Conor McLaughlin
Almost forced a winner after playing a good one-two with substitute McNulty, but unable to get forward much otherwise. Penalised for the early second-half foul that led to the equaliser. 5 Photo: FRANK REID
2. Jordan Willis
Battled well in the air and particularly in the first half, ensured the long balls from the visiting side had little influence. 6 Photo: FRANK REID
3. Joel Lynch
Fortunate late on when Hanlan got past him and fired a cross just too strong for the onrushing Oliver Lee. Otherwise comfortably and dominant in the air, Gillingham’s emphasis on set pieces bringing little reward. 6 Photo: FRANK REID 2019
4. Laurens De Bock
Should have had an assist when Maguire fired his fine cross wide. Rarely beaten defensively, but clearly does not offer the same threat from deep as Denver Hume. 6 Photo: FRANK REID