How they rated: Sunderland and Man City merit marks

TOP MAN? ... Sebastian Larsson in action against Manchester City. Picture by FRANK REID
TOP MAN? ... Sebastian Larsson in action against Manchester City. Picture by FRANK REID
Have your say

Not many Sunderland players came out of last night’s 4-1 def3eat at home to Manchester City with their reputations enhanced. CHRIS YOUNG gives his ratings on the Black Cats.

Pantilimon 5 – Had previously only conceded twice in four league games, but endured a miserable meeting with his former club. City’s finishing was excellent, yet the Romanian was nutmegged and twice beaten at his near post.

Vergini 5 – Played Aguero onside for the fourth and never looked comfortable up against Jovetic.

O’Shea 6 – Tried to hold the defence together, but gaps appeared in the Sunderland back line that weren’t evident against Chelsea

Coates 4 – Faced mission impossible after barely playing a game over the last 18 months and paid the price against the magnificent Aguero.

Reveillere 5 – Uncharacteristic couple of slack giveaways and looked leggy after his exertions against Chelsea.

Cattermole 6 – Perhaps inevitably was unable to exert the same influence as he did against Chelsea. Gave the ball away on a couple of occasions and went in the book.

LARSSON 7 – One of the few Sunderland players who looked like he still had some energy. Brilliant pass for Wickham’s goal.

Rodwell 6 – Should have given Sunderland an early lead against his former club, but did show flashes.

Buckley 5 – Set up a golden early opportunity for Rodwell, but produced precious little after that.

Wickham 7 – Persistence earned him a fortuitous second of the season and was one of Sunderland’s liveliest performers before being withdrawn (Alvarez 6 – Run–out will have done him the world of good after a couple of months on the sidelines)

Fletcher 5 – Forced off after a rugged challenge from behind by Boyata and spent too much time slipping on the deck (Altidore 6 – Tried to be the catalyst for a late comeback, but was fighting a lone battle).

MAN CITY: Hart 7, Zabaleta 8, Boyata 7, Demichelis 6, Clichy 7, Fernandinho 6, Toure 7, Nasri 8, Navas 7, Jovetic 8 (Milner 7), Aguero 9 (Lampard 7).

Do you agree with Chris? Was Seb Larsson your man of the match? Was Sebastian Coates as poor as suggested? Leave your comments below and tell us your ratings.