German death crash driver fined £5,000 after Sunderland biker killed

The scene of the fatal crash on the A19 at the Elwick Village junction. Pictures by Tom Collins.
The scene of the fatal crash on the A19 at the Elwick Village junction. Pictures by Tom Collins.
Have your say

A GERMAN driver who caused the death of a “magnificent dad” has been fined £5,000.

Physics teacher Thomas Menzel pulled out in front of a motorbike heading along the southbound carriageway of the A19.

Menzel, his wife and three daughters escaped serious injury in their Peugeot, but biker Thomas Brown, 71, from Sunderland, was pronounced dead at the scene after being thrown from his Suzuki.

The tragedy happened near Elwick village, on the outskirts of Hartlepool, after Menzel had been visiting family.

The 48-year-old admitted causing death by careless driving and told Mr Brown’s family, who had gathered in court, he was “extremely sorry” for what happened on July 21 last year.

Prosecutor Lynne Roberts-Plowman said a detailed police investigation led to the conclusion that Menzel should have been able to see the dad-of-one.

He was fined £5,000 and banned from driving in the UK for 12 months after Hartlepool Magistrates heard he had no previous convictions, could not have a community order as he lives in Germany and had shown “genuine remorse”.

A statement by Mr Brown’s wife Carol was read out.

“Tom was more than just a husband and a father,” she said. “He was totally devoted to us and spent his whole life taking care of us. I relied on him so much.

“As his wife, I would like to say the actions of the driver have totally devastated our family and have taken from us a deeply loved husband, father and respected uncle.”

Mr Brown and his son Adam had only returned from a five-week trip to Hong Kong and Australia in May, and were hoping to visit India later in the year.

“He was a truly magnificent dad and they did everything together,” the statement added.

In an unprecedented move, Menzel asked to address the family directly in court.

He was granted permission and told the full public gallery: “I’m extremely sorry for what happened to Mr Brown and the grief it caused, more now that I have heard the letter.

“My wife and I have been praying for you and I hope you can forgive me.

“If there’s anything we could do to lessen the pain we would do so.”

Tom Malarkey, mitigating, said Menzel was crossing the southbound carriageway to reach a central reservation before turning right towards Sunderland when the crash happened.

He added: “This wasn’t someone on a joyride. This is a family man who had children in the car.

“He wouldn’t have taken any risks if he had seen this vehicle and he doesn’t understand how he missed it.

“The report says he must have, and he will have to wrestle with why he didn’t see this man who was driving expertly on the road at that time.”

Twitter: @sunderlandecho